Lost Password?
  • Narrow screen resolution
  • Wide screen resolution
  • Auto width resolution
  • Increase font size
  • Decrease font size
  • Default font size
  • default color
  • red color
  • green color
Member Area

Samoalive News - The Latest Samoa News Headlines

Tuesday
Jan 06th
FrontPage arrow The News arrow Editor and Reader Opinions arrow Wars Count The Most Not Battles
Wars Count The Most Not Battles PDF Print E-mail
Written by Pio Sioa   
Wednesday, 19 March 2008
The RHD Bill was always going to go through as it did on Friday. There was little doubt about that from the start.
The great RHD debate was always going to be decided by the winning numbers Government had in Parliament.
The Prime Minister was so set on having the new policy in place, members of the HRPP party were made to decide between loyalty to the party and the wisdom of their own counsel and conscience.
After the debate was finally grinded to a halt and the question put to the vote, the final outcome was as expected.
The loud ayes from the Government members gave the RHD Bill the muscle it needed to pass the critical second reading.
The Prime Minister wanted the records to show also that not one of the nays was heard in the House – a final twist of the knife.
But while the Government had the muscle power, it still lacked the weight of conviction needed to reassure public opinion after a week of debating the issue.
There were too many negatives about the road switch that Government rhetoric failed to respond to with some credibility.
The Government argument was heavy on the emotional rhetoric and bare on the hard facts.
Government had to stoop to branding the business community as selfish rich people, out to deny the toil of the poor, car less families in the villages to get by.






In the final analysis, the third and final reading of the RHD Bill will be passed and be signed into law.
The writings are already on the wall.
But the issue is unlikely to end there. The country has become so embroiled in the debate, the way it was muscled through, has left so many concerns unanswered or yet to be believed.
Reassurances that public safety will not be a concern remains a nagging worry. If all 17 thousand cars switch to the wrong side of the road all at once, how unlikely are the chances that no accident will happen?
Why include in the RHD Bill an immunity clause preventing Government from being sued for negligence if any accident should occur during the switch over?
Are RHD vehicles that much cheaper than LHD cars?
Claims that the used car market in Japan was always the target from the start has been added as a new twist in the debate.
Did Government deliberately misled the country by playing on the emotions of relatives in New Zealand and Australia sending cars to families in Samoa?
These are only a few of the lingering issues that have and will continue to stick out for a long time to come on the RHD switch.
The protest by the People Against Switching Sides and the Institute of Professional Engineers are sound and well structured.
The fears expressed were genuine enough and the protest they mounted sincerely addressed safety and economic concerns.
PASS and IPES steered very clear of any political motives.
Unfortunately, it must be admitted that the issue they raised indirectly posed a political threat to the Government’s hold on power.
The Prime Minister and the HRPP reacted to the integrity of the protest with a political mindset rather than a conscientious evaluation of the issues protested against.
They ended up losing three of their members who voted with their conscience rather than bow to blind loyalty demanded from members of the party.
The Petitions Committee also made a total hash out of the report they tabled, the political influence was glaringly obvious, in the attempt to discredit the protesters concerns.
As for the protesters themselves, has the fight gone off their RHD campaign after the political pounding left the integrity of their concerns with a bloody nose?
Perhaps they can take heart from some very real positives they have obviously influenced in Samoa’s democracy.
For the first time since the general elections and the collapse of any recognized opposition in the House, the aimless plodding of members were finally sparked to life to vigorously challenge the overwhelming power of the Government.
There was an air of unity in their opposition. For the first time also, the country was shown a glimpse of the true fighting heart they are capable of.
The sense of unity was capped off by the former opposition leader, Le Mamea Ropati, when he finally broke his self imposed loss of interest for the first time, since the fall of the Samoa United Development Party.
The appeal of his wisdom, for Government to extend the time period before the RHD switch over, warmed the heart.
The cry for a stronger opposition has remained unheeded for so long. Has the RHD issue finally sparked a movement towards a legitimate opposition a true democracy in Samoa is crying out for?
Is part of the strong protest against the RHD road switch a natural turn of events, inspired by the call for a stronger opposition?
The voters are finally waking up to a new found reality they never thought possible until now – the power to influence their representatives in Parliament.
The influence of the power of the voters is a new political force that was never tapped, until the RHD protest showed the way.
The trend should be seriously encouraged as the most effective form of political persuasion to keep our politicians and our democracy honest to the wishes of the people.
From that perspective the RHD protest may have lost the battle against switching sides of the road, but they have opened up a whole new political theatre for democracy in Samoa to move forward.
This is an important victory the RHD protest has secured for the future of our strapping democracy.








Reddit!Del.icio.us!Facebook!Slashdot!Netscape!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Furl!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites! title=
Comments (1)Add Comment
Baby thrown out with bath water---
written by babybaby, March 19, 2008
Democracy is our Consensus Process within Village and District Discussion. We must fear One Party Rule or One Man Rule as a Rule of Thumb

Write comment
quote
bold
italicize
underline
strike
url
image
quote
quote
Smiley
Smiley
Smiley
Smiley
Smiley
Smiley
Smiley
Smiley
Smiley
Smiley
Smiley
Smiley

busy
Last Updated ( Thursday, 20 March 2008 )
 
< Prev   Next >

Polls


--ADVERTISEMENTS--


Google Satellite Map of Eveni Carruthers

--ADVERTISEMENTS--


"Where the natives buy and sell"


--ADVERTISEMENTS--

Latest Comments

Samoalivers Signing Off 2008
wink wink winkMalo lava le saasaa !!
Manu Samoa 7s Win in Uruguay
Congratulations Samoa 7s on the good job and well played games. I am proud of the the great effort p...
Manu Samoa 7s Win in Uruguay
Felicidades - Malo le taumafai and keep up the good work - Uruguay's strength is actually in soccer ...
Manu Samoa 7s Win in Uruguay
Faamalo atu i le tatou au.O lea foi ua toe faamanuiaina le au ale atunuu i faaga tama o le lakapi.fa...
Local Fans Eager For Tua vs Cameron Fight
Hi David Tua, Its your big fan from Arizona, I go onilne every week to find out when your next fight...

Social Network

Join the Newsline Team on Bebo

www.bebo.com/newslineS

Become part of the Newsline Bebo Network
 

Get News via your Email

Subscribe to Samoa Live News Headlines by Email


Get the Latest News on your Blackberry or PDA

Subscribe in a reader

 

 

Sounds from Samoa

Listen to broadcasts from LiveSamoa.com
Courtesy of Plantation Feet, SBC(540am) and
Radio Polynesia(99.9 FM)

http://www.samoalive.com/sliveradio.asx

Live on Weekdays from 8am to 9am

Have your Say

We want your Opinion

LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
If you would like to submit a letter for possible
publication in the print edition of the Newsline,
please send an email to This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it

We want your News

Submit News from your Area
If you would like to submit News for possible
publication in both the online and print version
of Newsline please feel free to email us 
at   This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it

Become a News Blogger
Have a passion for writing? Interested in
writing articles for Newsline? Email us
at This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it .
We are looking for Bloggers from
around the world to contribute to our site.

Who's Online

We have 5 guests online
Eveni Carruthers Online